| Most Recent |
|---|
| Green Hypocrisy’s Gold Standard |
|
|
| Written by Steven Milloy | |
| Wednesday, 19 September 2007 | |
|
Is billionaire
investor George Soros using environmental pressure groups to block a
gold-mining project for his own financial benefit?
Last week the Romanian
government suspended the environmental review process for Canadian company
Gabriel Resources’ proposed gold-mining project in the Transylvanian village of
Rosia
The ostensible reason for
the suspension was a court challenge filed by the local anti-development
activist group and the U.S.-based Open Society Institute about some paperwork
unrelated to the environmental review.
As discussed previously in
this column and in the documentary "Mine Your Own
Business," controversy over the mine has been fabricated by what has
seemed to be a leaderless and slapdash international collection of green
non-governmental organizations, or NGOs, all oddly focused on this one mining
project in a remote part of eastern Europe.
But the curtain is rising
on the NGOs’ efforts to stop the mine and it seems that Soros, through the Open
Society Institute he chairs, may be at the controls for reasons that have
little to do with protecting the environment.
A leaked October 2006
internal memo from an eastern European branch of Soros’ Open Society Institute
pleads for help from other central and eastern European NGOs to pressure the
Romanian government to stop the Rosia Montana mine, which the memo emphatically
(and bizarrely) refers to as a "resource curse."
The memo says the Rosia
Montana project "could become a landmark case for keeping bad government
in check" where "bad government," according to the tone of the
memo, seems to mean any action of which Open Society disapproves.
Could this memo reflect
nothing more than overzealous underlings acting without Soros’ personal
approval and direction? That explanation seems unlikely given Soros’ April 17,
2007, letter to Wayne Murdy, the chairman and CEO of Newmont Mining Corp., a
corporate shareholder in Gabriel Resources.
In the letter, Soros pressures
Murdy to use Newmont’s shareholder status to, in turn, pressure Gabriel
Resources. "I feel it is my duty to advise you to consider carefully any
further involvement with Gabriel Resources and the Rosia Montana project,"
Soros wrote.
This advice came with a
not-so-veiled threat to Newmont’s reputation: "I understand that Newmont
is committed to the highest standards of environmental management, employee
health and community safety. An investment in a dubious project such as Rosia
But what’s really dubious
is the game Soros seems to be playing.
The Rosia Montana is a
project that is designed to comply with all European and international
standards and will include a voluntary clean-up of a nearby mine that was in
operation from the time of the
According to a review by MineWeb.com,
It’s quite possible that
Soros' mining interests are even more extensive since the filings do not cover
his personal investments and other investments that don’t require reporting to
the SEC.
While Soros noted in his
letter to the Newmont CEO that the Romanian legislature was considering a ban
on the use of cyanide in mining, Soros recently purchased an interest in
Gabriel Resources’ competitor Goldcorp, which uses cyanide in its mining.
Soros’ criticism of Gabriel
Resources’ use of cyanide is even more bizarre given that the standard for
cyanide in mining waste under which the Rosia Montana project would operate is
about 10 times stricter than the
The Soros groups in
What’s with all this
hypocrisy on the part of Soros? Could it be that the estimated $10 billion in
gold that might be extracted from Rosia
Is it possible that Soros
is trying to torpedo Gabriel Resources’ project so that one of his own mining
interests can take over the Rosia Montana mine?
I would have liked to ask
George Soros these questions, but a call to the Open Society Institute was not
returned.
Soros’ shenanigans aside,
none of this inspires confidence in the Romanian government, which needs
foreign direct investment to fuel much-needed economic growth.
Although Gabriel Resources
so far has complied with the rule of law, the Romanian government nevertheless
seems to have bowed temporarily, at least to pressure from Soros-led NGOs.
This action should give
serious pause to Western companies contemplating investing in
Despite compliance with
applicable standards and substantial direct investments, Western companies may
well find themselves in a "Banana Republic" atmosphere where the rule
of law is disregarded, anti-development activists fronting for outside special
interests call the shots and anything goes.
Steven Milloy publishes
JunkScience.com and DemandDebate.com. He
is a junk science expert, and advocate of free
enterprise and an adjunct
scholar at the Competitive Enterprise Institute. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,297483,00.html
|
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|







