Response to Author Smith’s Critique of Christopher Monckton’s “Climate Sensitivity Reconsidered”

By | August 4, 2008

[Illustrations, footnotes and references available in PDF version]

"In the July 2008 edition of Physics and Society, a paper by Christopher Monckton entitled Climate Sensitivity Reconsidered caused considerable interest when the Society, which had invited Monckton to submit the paper and then published it, decided a week after publication, and without Monckton’s knowledge or consent, to add a prefatory disclaimer to the paper.

"Soon thereafter, a database manager for the American Physical Society, Arthur Smith, drafted and circulated a critique of Monckton’s paper. Smith’s critique and Monckton’s refutation of it are provided here for educational purposes."